International court from Roses in december

-
Q: Describe the procedure followed by the court in aiming at  its decision?
A:  International court follows most slowest and most complicated procedure which could possibly describe the ingenueinity of man. Hence, in all the 12 years of its existence it had decided not more than 30 cases.

*The court is bilingual with the two recognised language, English and French. The court also follow the process of translation if the argument the either language.

* There are no dialogues and arguments between judges and the bar. So that the art of advocacy is completely absent from the court.

Q: what are chgla's views on international court?
A: Chagla exclaims that there is no international law which is supreme and sovergien. There are treatise between states. Which have a binding force according to the country itself.
There is international customs and general principle of law recognised by civilised nation. Therefore, International law is neither definite nor precise.

Q: What is an international law?
A: international law is still in the process of  evolution although the United nations commissions have laid  down certain principles which are generally accepted as a body of rules. And which should be observed by all nations as governing international relations.

Q:  what is the deficiency of the IC?
A: THE IC may pass judgements or give decisions favouring one  country to another, it had no machinery to enforce its decisions.

Q: which case was concerned when Chagla was appointed in ICP?

A: The case before the court that Portugal claimed to have the right of passage through the territory  of  India in order to ensure communication between its territory of Raman and it's sub-territories of Dadra and Nagar haveli.

Q: what is the  role of security council to adequate the orders of international court?
A: security council to take adequate measures against the country which defies the  decision of the court. The security council go through with the process of the power of veto to each of the great powers, that machinery to say the least. The process has rarely been effective.

Q: comment upon the weaknesses of IC?
A: The procedure of veto power by the great powerful nations.

The appointments to the bench
Judges are elected for a term of nine years .the selection of the particular candidate .based on the majority of the notes in the security council and in the  UN assembly.

The rare chance of a judge carries the requirement of impartiality and detachment.

Q: what are chagla's views on his appointment as an ad-hoc judge in the IC?

A: chagla have had a very dissatisfactory remarks on this nomination. As the work he followed is actually a function of the advocate who appears before the court and not the function of  a judge.
According to him the judge is not there to fight the cause of his country but to arrive at a correct and impartial judgement.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Servents by Gieve Patel...poetry analysis

-
Critical appreciation:- Gieve Patel begins the poem with  very tragic sound and words.He expresses his remorse upon poor Indian servents who, comes from villages and sold their farming land for city life. He emphasises the pain of their heart and their mentality about insufficient places they acquire in the city. Therefore, he begins the poem from the night scene where lights are shuts down and darkness prevail around the scinario. This is the darkness of mind also, where people enters with their craving in the mind. The poet analyse their physical appearance,that all these servents who have been always departed from the luxurious life. Their skin colour turned black and their fingers are skinny and shiny because of they inhale cigrette. Smoke all the time by getting tired from their tough life style. As they also be habitual of tobacco chewinging so that an orange spot always mark on their rough palms.           In the second paragraph of the poem the poet describe about those who
Read more

Epilogue from Roses in December

-
Q: what is an epilogue? A: Epilogue is an introductory part in the manner of conclusion of some written document. The basic statements involve in the epilogue are the part of the major issues and the incidents mentioned in that written document. Q: When and how the emasculation of judiciary happen according to M.C CHAGLA? A: In the part of his autobiography the epilogue mention the time when the power of judiciary reduced. It was the time of emergency. Though Chagla  did not want to write upon this drastic movement of Indian History but his secularism and demand of time encourage him to write about this drastic period. Q: .What was Chagla's views about justice Ray? A: Chagla describe that justice Ray was characteristically dicurtiois and disloyal. He was the man of arrogance and vindictive and rude to those members of the bar who had taken an active part in the agitation against suppression. Q: What were the reasons of imposing emergency? A:India Gandhi brought about the
Read more
-
  Theme of The Battle of the books. The Quarrel between the Ancients and the Moderns Disputes among scholars concerning the superiority of classical Greek and Roman authors over contemporary writers have occurred at least since the time of the Renaissance. In the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, however, such debates turned into heated conflicts, particularly in France and England. In these two countries the Querelle des Anciens et des Modernes and the Battle of the Books pitted the Ancients—who upheld the authority of the writers of antiquity in intellectual matters—against the Moderns—who maintained that writers of the present day possessed greater knowledge and more-refined tastes than their predecessors. Underlying these positions were fundamental assumptions regarding the state of art, culture, and human knowledge. The Ancients viewed Greco-Roman civilization as the apex of human achievement and all subsequent culture as a decline from this high point. Thus, the
Read more